| The US Department of
Transportation, Federal Highway Administration Conference on Cardiac
Disorders and Commercial drivers came up with the following, in summary.
1.
Sinus and Primary Atrial Arrhythmias
-
Sinus
arrhythmia was considered a normal variant of no consequence.
-
Symptomatic
sinus bradycardia or tachycardia is abnormal and requires a search for
it s cause.
-
Asymptomatic
sinus bradycardia or tachycardia in the absence of underlying relevant
diseases should not be disqualifying.
-
Isolated
atrial premature beats (symptomatic or not) and not requiring therapy
were not considered disqualifying.
-
Atrial
fibrillation and flutter are usually associated with disease states
and should preclude commercial driving until adequately evaluated and
treated.
-
Multifocal
atrial tachycardia is usually associated with serious underlying
metabolic or pulmonary disease. Patients with this arrhythmia should
not be considered fit for driving.
2.
Junctional rhythms and Paroxysmal Supraventricular Tachycardia
-
Non-paroxysmal
junctional tachycardia was considered to be closely associated with
disease states and digitalis toxicity. Medical evaluation is required
and driving permitted only if the arrhythmia is asymptomatic and
cardiac disease states are excluded.
-
Paroxysmal
supraventricular tachycardia (SVT) was considered acceptable if
well controlled with any acceptable medical regiment. The same
recommendation was provided for patients with ventricular
pre-excitation (eg, Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome), and this subset
is not qualified for commercial motor vehicle operation.
3.
Ventricular Dysrhythmia
-
Low
grade 3 and above (ie. multiform premature complexes, couplets, three
or more consecutively , and R-on-T phenomenon) ventricular arrhythmias
were disqualifying unless cleared by a cardiologist on a case-by-case
basis.
-
Sustained
or non-sustained ventricular tachycardia, whether symptomatic or not,
was considered disqualifying.
4.
Heart Block
-
First-and
second-degree type 1 atrioventricular (AV) block were not
considered problematic. The implication of narrow versus wide QRS
complexes in the setting of second-degree type 1 AV block was not
addressed.
-
Second-degree
type 11 AV and third-degree AV block were considered
disqualifying. Congenital AV block was not addressed.
-
Bundle-branch
blocks and fascicular blocks should prompt a search for evidence of
intrinsic cardiac abnormalities, but in the absence of such diseases
they should not be disqualifying.
5.
Pacemakers
-
The
majority opinion concluded that insertion of a pacemaker should not in
itself be disqualifying, although specialized follow-up was advised.
However, a dissenting minority opinion recommending disqualification
was included in the report. This opinion recommended
disqualification due to total lack of certainty for pacemaker
operation. The concept of pacemaker dependency was not addressed.
6.
Sudden Death
-
For
patients who have survived cardiac arrest, the consensus of the
conference was that they still carry a substantial risk of additional
episodes and should not be considered fit for commercial driving
irrespective of the success of subsequent therapy. The impact of ISD
treatment was not a consideration at the time of the report.
7.
Cardiovascular Pharmacological Agents
-
For
patients receiving beta blockers, concern was raised regarding
impaired mental alertness and development of depression and
somnolence. Case-by-case decisions with respect to driving
qualification were implied. In general, calcium channel blockers were
accorded a higher level of safety with respect to driving risk.
-
In
regard to Vaughn Williams Class 1 and 111 agents, the conference
provided a timely warning against use of antiarrhythmic agents for
common benign arrhythmias, pointing out that they often provided no
benefit and often cause a worsening of ectopy. They recommended that
patients who require such drugs undergo a comparative evaluation
before and afterward. The specifics of the recommended evaluations
would now be considered inadequate and therefore are not included
here.
|